A bit about Russian business of Scartel
Iota is now one of the main newsmakers in the market of telecom operators. This is, of course, connected with the murky story of receiving and taking frequencies. I would like to share some articles and my opinion.
LTE not on Yota - PCWeek.
Let's think it over. But was it necessary to work like this? Is there really no way more honest. At least comparatively. Yes, everyone knows that mobile operators cut down cell towers without waiting for permission. In this case, paying a fine is more profitable than not including the connection. But still, some facts speak for themselves.
I suggest that you familiarize yourself with the table (pdf, 800 KB) prepared by Alexei Boyko (www.mforum.ru). " ... the Yota frequency permissions machine worked without interruption, in particular, only from March to May 2010, this company was issued about 200 (!!) frequency permissions ." - Quote from the LiveJournal community ru_4g . And this despite the fact that “ ... the radio frequency resource 2.5-2.7 GHz a year ago, in August 2009, was recognized as a limited resource, which is“ subject to distribution by tender or auction. ”But this is the rule for“ Scartel ”for which for some reason it didn’t apply - to the company’s available frequencies with a “width” of 40 MHz it received almost the same amount ... without a competition". Denis Sverdlov has his own arguments in this regard. This is not surprising.
We have the sensational order of Roskomnadzor under number 510. Moreover, according to various sources, this order is dated April 27, 2010 (it is easy to google in news feeds), or July 27, 2010 (see article). What is interesting is the first date. If the order is indeed dated April 27, 2010, then it invalidates the permission to use radio frequencies or radio frequency channels dated May 4, 2010 . Did the ordering officials foresee that Iota would receive frequencies on May 4? Unfortunately, it is worth noting that the website of Roskomnadzor is silent on this matter .
Another point that at least indirectly shows that Iota licenses were issued (or extended?) Through the stump deck. Take license number 67898. On the site of Iota, the start date for the provision of services is May 11, 2010 . On the website of Roskomnadzor, we have a different term - November 11, 2010 . If this was an extension, then it was done quietly, like everything that is happening inside Scartel. But, given the fact that there is a state corporation in the shareholders of Scartel (I think we all know how state-owned corporations and other spin-off state structures resolve issues), we can assume that this is an ordinary bureaucratic mess. But I want to believe in the best.
Further, the opinions of telecom analysts and experts diverge. I am inclined to agree with some statements.
Well, in conclusion I will say. Everything that Scartel is doing now, I do not approve. It seems to me that there is still time and opportunity to turn in the other direction and move in the right direction. I don’t know where. But not to the side “we’ll take it right now and will build LTE faster than anyone else, as WiMax is the fastest built” Moreover, the investments of the state-owned Russian Technologies Corporation in Scartel are essentially our investments with you. This people earned the money that Russian Technologies invested in Scartel. And we do not need the next drilling rigs for VTB.
So it goes.
LTE not on Yota - PCWeek.
Let's think it over. But was it necessary to work like this? Is there really no way more honest. At least comparatively. Yes, everyone knows that mobile operators cut down cell towers without waiting for permission. In this case, paying a fine is more profitable than not including the connection. But still, some facts speak for themselves.
Frequency Resolution Machine
I suggest that you familiarize yourself with the table (pdf, 800 KB) prepared by Alexei Boyko (www.mforum.ru). " ... the Yota frequency permissions machine worked without interruption, in particular, only from March to May 2010, this company was issued about 200 (!!) frequency permissions ." - Quote from the LiveJournal community ru_4g . And this despite the fact that “ ... the radio frequency resource 2.5-2.7 GHz a year ago, in August 2009, was recognized as a limited resource, which is“ subject to distribution by tender or auction. ”But this is the rule for“ Scartel ”for which for some reason it didn’t apply - to the company’s available frequencies with a “width” of 40 MHz it received almost the same amount ... without a competition". Denis Sverdlov has his own arguments in this regard. This is not surprising.
I gave birth to you, I will kill you!
We have the sensational order of Roskomnadzor under number 510. Moreover, according to various sources, this order is dated April 27, 2010 (it is easy to google in news feeds), or July 27, 2010 (see article). What is interesting is the first date. If the order is indeed dated April 27, 2010, then it invalidates the permission to use radio frequencies or radio frequency channels dated May 4, 2010 . Did the ordering officials foresee that Iota would receive frequencies on May 4? Unfortunately, it is worth noting that the website of Roskomnadzor is silent on this matter .
The left hand does not know what the right hand is doing.
Another point that at least indirectly shows that Iota licenses were issued (or extended?) Through the stump deck. Take license number 67898. On the site of Iota, the start date for the provision of services is May 11, 2010 . On the website of Roskomnadzor, we have a different term - November 11, 2010 . If this was an extension, then it was done quietly, like everything that is happening inside Scartel. But, given the fact that there is a state corporation in the shareholders of Scartel (I think we all know how state-owned corporations and other spin-off state structures resolve issues), we can assume that this is an ordinary bureaucratic mess. But I want to believe in the best.
What to do?
Further, the opinions of telecom analysts and experts diverge. I am inclined to agree with some statements.
- Iota will be able to launch the LTE network. In Russia, all issues are resolved. Will Iota be an All-Russian LTE operator? Unlikely. Even the numbering capacity of 1000 numbers still does not mean anything.
- All the actions that Iota is now taking are aimed at selling themselves more expensively. Attracting new investors to build the LTE network is a practically impossible task.
Well, in conclusion I will say. Everything that Scartel is doing now, I do not approve. It seems to me that there is still time and opportunity to turn in the other direction and move in the right direction. I don’t know where. But not to the side “we’ll take it right now and will build LTE faster than anyone else, as WiMax is the fastest built” Moreover, the investments of the state-owned Russian Technologies Corporation in Scartel are essentially our investments with you. This people earned the money that Russian Technologies invested in Scartel. And we do not need the next drilling rigs for VTB.
So it goes.