May 21, 2013 at 14:41Tunnel simulation v 0.1. Spherical worldview model. Presentation of ideology
- Tutorial
Good reading time, dear participants of habrahabr.ru
The reaction of habrahabr.ru otkhambrivaniya participants to three publications and some questions that (in the opinion of the author) revealed the idea quite fully, led to the idea that the idea needs to be expressed clearly enough.
Links to previous publications will be given at the end of the post. At the same time, I ask you to consider the author not as a mentor, but as a learning amateur who is fixated on the idea.
A special case is the Anokhin functional loop www.zooton.net
First of all, I declare that in this presentation there is no description of a specific example.
Laboratory work using the methodology prepared by working with customers, the programmer will be able to perform himself. The minimum size of the analysis matrix is one sheet. The minimum size of the full model is 36 sheets of A4 or A5 format, the nominal size is 46 sheets for the simplest model without detail. This may outrage someone, to which I will answer that simpler models have long been used, and this methodology allows further extensive development through an intensive leap in understanding simplicity.
So, you already understood that the further will be interesting only to those who made the flowchart or description of the task in two sheets or more. I thank everyone asking questions for clarifying my understanding.
One of the main questions was the question of essence. I will try to tell.
First of all, the abstractness scale is introduced, which is based on two reference points:
1. The idea of the existence of an idea with 100% abstractness
2. Emptiness with 0% abstractness
For programmers, the concept of the level of abstractness is more natural than for other specialists. For tunnel modeling, abstractness is considered finite, and the measurement can be expressed as a percentage - from 0% to 100%. At the same time, 100% of abstractness corresponds to the concept of an idea. Yes, there are no clues for consciousness. Fuzzy logic comes to the rescue.
In the methodology of tunnel modeling, it is postulated that nine levels are distinguished ( Abstract and an open system interaction model )
In this case, philosophical concepts are used, which reserve areas of 0% -5% and 95% -100% abstractness for more specific studies, and for conventional modeling, there remain ranges with centers that are multiples of 10%:
from 5% to 15% with a center of 10%
from 15% to 25% with a center of 20%
, etc.
It should be noted that in the general case, membership functions are fuzzy, incl. - possible distribution with normal distribution.
Accordingly, the ranges can "fit" one on top of the other, which confuses our direct perception.
For the presentation, a deeper understanding of this approach is unnecessary. (And I did not conduct further research in this direction. And it is unlikely that this will correspond to my specialization as a practicing programmer. This is, rather, the field of philologists, where I have a stable 2+ in the school grading system).
So, I finish the description of the abstract scale. We pass to the second coordinate.
She is trickier, although Deming expressed it remarkably in the form of a -Plan-Do-Check-Act- loop. I note that without the discovery of the subconscious (Act) by Freud, this idea was hardly possible.
So here we are dealing with feedback.
Moreover, this feedback is not direct, as is usually portrayed, but dialectical. That is, before reaching the reanalysis of the correctness, the signal goes through other stages:
- planning (forecasting the correctness of the idea)
- execution (checking the feasibility of the plan)
- verification (comparing the plan and the fact).
This model coincides with the functional loop of P.K. Anokhin in relation to a person.
I note that in the framework of the proposed model, the correspondence is also fuzzy.
Let's move on to the main idea. Suppose there is a vertical scale of abstraction and a horizontal round scale of the phases of the Deming cycle.
It is difficult to call their union Cartesian product. Rather, we get a cylindrical coordinate system.
The following messages were devoted to the description of this coordinate system as applied to information technology:
Abstractness and model of interaction of open systems
Open Systems Interaction Model, Deming Cycle and Tunnel Modeling
Tunnel Modeling v0.1 - Pseudocode
The reaction of habrahabr.ru otkhambrivaniya participants to three publications and some questions that (in the opinion of the author) revealed the idea quite fully, led to the idea that the idea needs to be expressed clearly enough.
Links to previous publications will be given at the end of the post. At the same time, I ask you to consider the author not as a mentor, but as a learning amateur who is fixated on the idea.
A special case is the Anokhin functional loop www.zooton.net
First of all, I declare that in this presentation there is no description of a specific example.
Laboratory work using the methodology prepared by working with customers, the programmer will be able to perform himself. The minimum size of the analysis matrix is one sheet. The minimum size of the full model is 36 sheets of A4 or A5 format, the nominal size is 46 sheets for the simplest model without detail. This may outrage someone, to which I will answer that simpler models have long been used, and this methodology allows further extensive development through an intensive leap in understanding simplicity.
So, you already understood that the further will be interesting only to those who made the flowchart or description of the task in two sheets or more. I thank everyone asking questions for clarifying my understanding.
One of the main questions was the question of essence. I will try to tell.
First of all, the abstractness scale is introduced, which is based on two reference points:
1. The idea of the existence of an idea with 100% abstractness
2. Emptiness with 0% abstractness
For programmers, the concept of the level of abstractness is more natural than for other specialists. For tunnel modeling, abstractness is considered finite, and the measurement can be expressed as a percentage - from 0% to 100%. At the same time, 100% of abstractness corresponds to the concept of an idea. Yes, there are no clues for consciousness. Fuzzy logic comes to the rescue.
In the methodology of tunnel modeling, it is postulated that nine levels are distinguished ( Abstract and an open system interaction model )
In this case, philosophical concepts are used, which reserve areas of 0% -5% and 95% -100% abstractness for more specific studies, and for conventional modeling, there remain ranges with centers that are multiples of 10%:
from 5% to 15% with a center of 10%
from 15% to 25% with a center of 20%
, etc.
It should be noted that in the general case, membership functions are fuzzy, incl. - possible distribution with normal distribution.
Accordingly, the ranges can "fit" one on top of the other, which confuses our direct perception.
For the presentation, a deeper understanding of this approach is unnecessary. (And I did not conduct further research in this direction. And it is unlikely that this will correspond to my specialization as a practicing programmer. This is, rather, the field of philologists, where I have a stable 2+ in the school grading system).
So, I finish the description of the abstract scale. We pass to the second coordinate.
She is trickier, although Deming expressed it remarkably in the form of a -Plan-Do-Check-Act- loop. I note that without the discovery of the subconscious (Act) by Freud, this idea was hardly possible.
So here we are dealing with feedback.
Moreover, this feedback is not direct, as is usually portrayed, but dialectical. That is, before reaching the reanalysis of the correctness, the signal goes through other stages:
- planning (forecasting the correctness of the idea)
- execution (checking the feasibility of the plan)
- verification (comparing the plan and the fact).
This model coincides with the functional loop of P.K. Anokhin in relation to a person.
I note that in the framework of the proposed model, the correspondence is also fuzzy.
Let's move on to the main idea. Suppose there is a vertical scale of abstraction and a horizontal round scale of the phases of the Deming cycle.
It is difficult to call their union Cartesian product. Rather, we get a cylindrical coordinate system.
The following messages were devoted to the description of this coordinate system as applied to information technology:
Abstractness and model of interaction of open systems
Open Systems Interaction Model, Deming Cycle and Tunnel Modeling
Tunnel Modeling v0.1 - Pseudocode