Candidates of Sciences may be canceled, but will not be
Now the scientific world is undergoing reform. Subject to change are the Higher Attestation Commission, Dissertation Councils and, most importantly, degrees of sciences. It is discussed that in the near future, Russia will move to a European system of conferring scientific titles. And this will lead to the closure of candidate dissertation councils and to the abolition of the degree of candidate of sciences .
In 2003, Russia joined the Bologna process, which unifies the standards of education and scientific activity. In the framework of this process, the ladder of scientific ranks in domestic science should become the same as in Europe: bachelor, master and doctor. The title of bachelor and master will be awarded by the university, and the title of doctor - dissertation councils. “There are no candidate councils in the new draft regulation on dissertation councils.” Said Elena Nechaeva, Director of the Department of Scientific and Scientific-Pedagogical Personnel of the Ministry of Education and Science.
According to the new system of academic degrees, there are:
Bachelor - holder of a university degree (bachelor of arts, bachelor of science, bachelor of education).
master- holder of a university degree (master of arts, master of science) - “master of philosophy” (M. Phil). In other words, this is a proto-doctoral degree characterizing its holder as a candidate for a doctor.
Doctor of Science - holder of a Doctor of Science degree (European Ph.D.)
The reform process implies several fundamental changes:
1. Only selected universities (not lower than research status) should be entitled to master's programs.
2. It is radically necessary to reduce the number of dissertation councils, to substantially strengthen the composition of the expert councils of the Higher Attestation Commission.
3. Master dissertations should be independently certified, and not just finally approved in the "native" university.
4. Graduate studies should be changed to Ph.D. departments (departments of doctoral students) with a completely different curriculum, where each course is a discussion of world scientific achievements over the past 3-4 years. Such a program should take two years. Supervisors of doctoral students should only be doctors of sciences, especially with a Ph.D. And three years should be allocated to the actual preparation of the dissertation.
The conclusion from the above: the reform of the system of academic degrees requires preliminary profound changes in the entire university system of Russia and no less profound changes in the activities of Rosobrnadzor and the Higher Attestation Commission.
Good luck to all!
Pruflinki:
Ministry of Education and Science cancels candidates of sciences
All this crowd will begin to mass produce masters - candidates for a doctor of science
UPDATE
Thank you sHinE and r4tz52 clarified thanks to the link to the website of the Higher Attestation Commission:
news “On the scientific degree of a candidate of science”
Recently, there have been reports in some media about the plans of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation to abolish the scientific degree of a candidate of science in the state system of certification of scientific and scientific and pedagogical workers. Most likely, this conclusion was made on the basis of a number of statements made during the discussion at the “Round Table” held at the Russian Ministry of Education and Science on November 17, 2011, of the draft regulation on the council for the defense of dissertations for the degree of candidate of science, for the degree of Doctors of Science.
In this regard, the Department of Scientific and Scientific-Pedagogical Personnel of the Russian Ministry of Education and Science declares that this conclusion is not true .
Currently, the Government of the Russian Federation dated January 30, 2002 No. 74 approved the Unified Register of Academic Degrees and Scientific Ranks, which sets the following academic degrees for scientific and scientific-pedagogical personnel of higher qualification:
- Doctor of Science degree in the field of science according to the nomenclature specialties of scientists;
- Ph.D. degree in the field of science according to the nomenclature of specialties of scientists.
It is not planned to amend the indicated Unified Register regarding cancellation of the scientific degree of a candidate of sciences .
In 2003, Russia joined the Bologna process, which unifies the standards of education and scientific activity. In the framework of this process, the ladder of scientific ranks in domestic science should become the same as in Europe: bachelor, master and doctor. The title of bachelor and master will be awarded by the university, and the title of doctor - dissertation councils. “There are no candidate councils in the new draft regulation on dissertation councils.” Said Elena Nechaeva, Director of the Department of Scientific and Scientific-Pedagogical Personnel of the Ministry of Education and Science.
According to the new system of academic degrees, there are:
Bachelor - holder of a university degree (bachelor of arts, bachelor of science, bachelor of education).
master- holder of a university degree (master of arts, master of science) - “master of philosophy” (M. Phil). In other words, this is a proto-doctoral degree characterizing its holder as a candidate for a doctor.
Doctor of Science - holder of a Doctor of Science degree (European Ph.D.)
The reform process implies several fundamental changes:
1. Only selected universities (not lower than research status) should be entitled to master's programs.
2. It is radically necessary to reduce the number of dissertation councils, to substantially strengthen the composition of the expert councils of the Higher Attestation Commission.
3. Master dissertations should be independently certified, and not just finally approved in the "native" university.
4. Graduate studies should be changed to Ph.D. departments (departments of doctoral students) with a completely different curriculum, where each course is a discussion of world scientific achievements over the past 3-4 years. Such a program should take two years. Supervisors of doctoral students should only be doctors of sciences, especially with a Ph.D. And three years should be allocated to the actual preparation of the dissertation.
The conclusion from the above: the reform of the system of academic degrees requires preliminary profound changes in the entire university system of Russia and no less profound changes in the activities of Rosobrnadzor and the Higher Attestation Commission.
Good luck to all!
Pruflinki:
Ministry of Education and Science cancels candidates of sciences
All this crowd will begin to mass produce masters - candidates for a doctor of science
UPDATE
Thank you sHinE and r4tz52 clarified thanks to the link to the website of the Higher Attestation Commission:
news “On the scientific degree of a candidate of science”
Recently, there have been reports in some media about the plans of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation to abolish the scientific degree of a candidate of science in the state system of certification of scientific and scientific and pedagogical workers. Most likely, this conclusion was made on the basis of a number of statements made during the discussion at the “Round Table” held at the Russian Ministry of Education and Science on November 17, 2011, of the draft regulation on the council for the defense of dissertations for the degree of candidate of science, for the degree of Doctors of Science.
In this regard, the Department of Scientific and Scientific-Pedagogical Personnel of the Russian Ministry of Education and Science declares that this conclusion is not true .
Currently, the Government of the Russian Federation dated January 30, 2002 No. 74 approved the Unified Register of Academic Degrees and Scientific Ranks, which sets the following academic degrees for scientific and scientific-pedagogical personnel of higher qualification:
- Doctor of Science degree in the field of science according to the nomenclature specialties of scientists;
- Ph.D. degree in the field of science according to the nomenclature of specialties of scientists.
It is not planned to amend the indicated Unified Register regarding cancellation of the scientific degree of a candidate of sciences .